20.6 Metabolic Acidosis from a Failing Kidney

Time To Read

24–36 minutes

Date Last Modified

Fluids, Electrolytes & Acid–Base Balance · Chapter 6 of 7

An arterial blood gas is four numbers and three questions: acid or base? lungs or kidney? is anyone compensating? This chapter builds the method with the notes’ thresholds, lays out the four disturbances and their causes, shows compensation stopping at the edge of the range, runs the site’s ABG game, and then asks what a kidney that cannot excrete the day’s acid or make new bicarbonate does to potassium, to bone and to a pH the lungs can only partly rescue.

The question you will answer

When the kidney cannot fix an acidosis, the lungs try. Why can they only get partway — and what can a healthy kidney do that they cannot?

Opener · Three Questions, Four Numbers · about 1¾ minutes

The opener is the same narrated animation you will watch in Scene 1.

Watch the opener first. It sets the question; the chapter answers it.

1

Read the chart

Patient chart · Stina

2025 · age 50

ABG
pH 7.33 · PCO₂ 33 · HCO₃⁻ 19 · PO₂ 94. Anion gap 10.

Read
Step A: pH < 7.35 → acidosis. Step B: PCO₂ < 35 → metabolic cause, respiratory system IS compensating. Step C: HCO₃⁻ < 22 → metabolic acidosis. Partially compensated.

Kidney
eGFR 48; creatinine 1.3; potassium 4.9; phosphate 4.4; urine pH 5.0; ammonium excretion low for the degree of acidosis.

Bone
DEXA at 38 low (the Skeletal module). Bone is the body’s slow buffer.

For contrast
Mr. Wu: pH 7.28, PCO₂ 28, HCO₃⁻ 14, respirations 22/min — renal acidosis, partially compensated, further along.

Told
Nothing; the gas was filed.


Chart clues this module: 1 · The ankles · 2 · Compartments · 3 · The pull · 4 · The calcium · 5 · Buffers · 6 · this chapter

Before you go on · your prediction

pH 7.33, PCO₂ 33, HCO₃⁻ 19, breathing a little deep. Her lungs…

Open the one you lean toward. Nothing is recorded and nothing is revealed — you come back to it at the end.

Have failed to compensate — a compensated acidosis would have a normal pH

Ask what “partial” means and where compensation is supposed to stop. Then ask whether a pH of 7.33 without the lungs would be 7.33.

Are compensating as far as lungs can — they can blow off CO₂ but cannot make bicarbonate or excrete a fixed acid

Ask which end of the reaction the lungs own, and what the acid load of a day is made of. Then ask what a healthy kidney would be doing with glutamine right now.

Are the problem — a low CO₂ is a respiratory disturbance by definition

Ask which way pH moves when a low CO₂ is the cause, and compare with hers. Then run the notes’ three questions in order.

2

The story

Three short movements: the case, the anatomy and physiology, then the tie back to Stina. Each links to the scene where you’ll see it move.

I · Four numbers, filed

An arterial gas is a needle in an artery, not a vein, because venous blood is carbon-dioxide-rich and oxygen-poor by design and would tell you nothing. Hers came back pH 7.33, carbon dioxide 33, bicarbonate 19, oxygen 94, and was filed without a word. The notes read it in three steps. Is it acidosis or alkalosis? Below 7.35: acidosis. Is it respiratory or metabolic? Carbon dioxide below 35: metabolic, and the respiratory system is compensating. Is the bicarbonate low? Nineteen, below 22: metabolic acidosis. Partially compensated, because the pH is still outside the range. Mr. Wu, the site’s case patient, is the same shape further down the road — 7.28, 14, twenty-two breaths a minute — a man whose lungs are doing the job of his kidneys as hard as lungs can.

See it move: Scene 1 · Three Questions, Four Numbers · Scene 3 · Compensation: the Healthy Organ Steps Up

II · Four disturbances, and the healthy organ steps up

The ABG lecture says it plainly: different references use different steps; pick one and stick to it. The notes’ three questions with their numbers are the course’s reference, and the four disturbances are named for the end that moved first. Respiratory acidosis: CO₂ up, pH down — hypoventilation, pneumonia, emphysema, heart failure, an inhaled toy. Respiratory alkalosis: CO₂ down, pH up — hyperventilation from fear, fever, hypoxia, an aspirin overdose’s first act. Metabolic acidosis: bicarbonate down, pH down — diarrhea losing bicarbonate; ketones in a starving or diabetic body, with the deep fruity breathing of ketoacidosis; lactate in a sprint or a shock; methanol, ethylene glycol; and uremia, the phosphoric, sulfuric and lactic acids a failing kidney cannot clear. Metabolic alkalosis: bicarbonate up, pH up — vomiting, antacids, diuretics, Cushing’s. The lecture’s shortcut: in a renal disturbance every number moves the same way; in a respiratory one the pH moves opposite to the CO₂. Then compensation: the organ not at fault drags the pH back. In a metabolic acidosis the low pH drives the respiratory centres within minutes — Kussmaul respirations when severe, a sign you can see — and CO₂ falls. In a respiratory disturbance the kidney compensates over days. The rule the lecture insists on: compensation stops at the edge of the range, not the middle; it buys time, it does not cure.

See it move: Scene 2 · Four Disturbances, Their Causes · Scene 3 · Compensation: the Healthy Organ Steps Up · Scene 4 · The ABG Game

III · When the slow partner fails

Her problem is that the slow, durable partner is the organ that is failing. A kidney with amyloid stiffening its glomeruli and crowding its interstitium is losing two acid–base jobs at once. It cannot excrete the day’s fixed acid: the phosphate, sulfate and organic acids of ordinary metabolism, forty to seventy milliequivalents a day, which only a kidney removes. And it cannot make new bicarbonate fast enough: the glutamine machine of Chapter 5 runs slow, ammonium in the urine falls, and the alkaline reserve is not refilled. The acid is buffered where it can be — by bicarbonate, by hemoglobin, by the phosphate inside cells, and, over years, by bone, which gives up calcium carbonate to soak a chronic acid load and thins as it does; the Skeletal module’s low scan at thirty-eight has one more author. Potassium rides along: hydrogen ions move into cells and potassium moves out, and a kidney that struggles to excrete potassium at the best of times is now handed more of it — her 4.9. Her lungs do what lungs do: breathe a little deeper, blow off CO₂, pull the pH from where it would be to 7.33. They can work the CO₂ end for as long as she breathes. They cannot manufacture a single bicarbonate ion or excrete a single sulfate. The compensation is partial by design: a patch over a hole the lungs were never built to fill. The fix is not a bag of bicarbonate, though one may be hung; it is the organ. Protect the filter, slow the amyloid, and the acid load stops growing.

See it move: Scene 4 · The ABG Game · Scene 5 · When the Slow Partner Fails

3

Watch · explore · think · check

5 scenes. Each one has a short animation or a slide, something to explore, a true/false spot-check of your thinking, and a quick check. Every scene gives you an evidence card for your board.

How to read the scenes

  • Animation (dark teal) — a short animated explainer, one idea each
  • Slide (dark teal) — a still to study: a micrograph, a diagram or a map
  • Explore (purple) — something to push on while you watch
  • Game (purple) — a quick challenge
  • Think (gold) — reason it out, then spot-check yourself with a few true/false questions; not graded
  • Check (gold) — a quick H5P that scores itself

Scene 1 of 5

Three Questions, Four Numbers

Acid or base? Lungs or kidney? Is anyone helping?

Animation · in production · 1 min 50 s

Three Questions, Four Numbers

Arterial puncture vs venipuncture (venous blood is CO₂-rich by design). The four numbers: pH, PCO₂, HCO₃⁻, PO₂. Step A: pH < 7.35 acidosis, > 7.45 alkalosis. Step B: PCO₂ > 45 respiratory cause; < 35 metabolic with respiratory compensation; 35–45 metabolic cause. Step C: HCO₃⁻ < 22 metabolic acidosis, > 26 metabolic alkalosis. The lecture’s shortcut (renal: all down or all up; respiratory: pH opposite). Her gas read live: acidosis → metabolic, lungs compensating → bicarbonate low → partially compensated metabolic acidosis.

Prefer the full lecture? Bicarbonate Buffer System (original video on the site)

Game

Read it in three

Card table

Eight gases lie face down. Turn one number at a time in the notes’ order, pH, then PCO₂, then HCO₃⁻, and commit after each turn. Score against yourself.

Text description of this game

A card table with eight arterial blood gases dealt face down: Stina; Mr. Wu; a toddler who inhaled a toy; an exam-panic hyperventilator; a diabetic in ketoacidosis; a normal routine check; a vomiter; and a marathoner sprinting the last mile. Each card shows three number tiles, pH, PCO₂ (mm Hg) and HCO₃⁻ (mEq/L); a face-down tile is patterned and read as “face down”. Step 1 (step A): only the pH is face up; call each gas acidosis, normal or alkalosis. Step 2 (step B): the PCO₂ turns over; name each gas respiratory acidosis, respiratory alkalosis, metabolic acidosis, metabolic alkalosis, or normal so far. Step 3 (step C): the bicarbonate turns over; call each uncompensated, partially compensated, fully compensated, or normal with nothing to compensate. After each commit every card shows whether your call holds, why, and whether you could have stopped there, with a tally of how many you placed. The gases: toy 7.26, 60, 26; Stina 7.33, 33, 19; hyperventilator 7.57, 25, 22; ketoacidosis 7.17, 17, 6; normal 7.40, 40, 24; vomiter 7.50, 46, 35; marathoner 7.31, 31, 15; Mr. Wu 7.28, 28, 14. Step 4, the trap: a ninth gas arrives with a note that every number is low; name it before step B (metabolic acidosis with the lungs compensating, respiratory alkalosis, respiratory acidosis, or “it cannot be named without the numbers”), then the gas is shown: 7.30, 25, 12.

Think · not graded

The notes’ step B says a CO₂ below 35 in an acidosis means “metabolic, and the lungs are compensating”. What would the same CO₂ mean beside a pH of 7.50 — and why does the order of the three questions matter more than any single threshold?

Spot-check your thinking: true or false?

Check · Drag the Words

Sort disturbances into the acidosis/alkalosis, respiratory/metabolic grid.

Evidence card 1

Add it to your evidence board

Three questions in order: acidosis, metabolic, lungs helping, bicarbonate low — partially compensated.

Scene 2 of 5

Four Disturbances, Their Causes

The grid, filled with real patients.

Slide · a still to study

Causes, Signs and the Potassium Link

Four disturbances, typical causes

  • Respiratory acidosis: too little breathing: pneumonia, emphysema, opioids, a blocked airway.
  • Respiratory alkalosis: too much breathing: fear, fever, hypoxia, early aspirin overdose.
  • Metabolic acidosis: diarrhea, ketoacidosis, lactic acidosis, methanol or ethylene glycol, kidney failure, renal tubular acidosis.
  • Metabolic alkalosis: vomiting, antacids, some diuretics, Cushing’s syndrome.

Signs

  • Acidosis: headache, confusion, lethargy, deep breathing, arrhythmia.
  • Alkalosis: tingling, twitching, tremor.

The potassium link

  • Acidosis often raises serum potassium as H⁺ enters cells and K⁺ leaves; alkalosis lowers it.
  • Diarrhea is the exception: it loses potassium as well as bicarbonate.

Every row is a patient the site has met — and one is her.

Prefer the full lecture? Bicarbonate Buffer System (original video on the site)

Explore

Fill the grid

Cause grid

Twelve causes, one 2×2 grid. Sort them, predict the potassium and a bedside sign for each, then find the causes that make two disturbances at once.

Text description of this explore

A two-by-two grid: columns acidosis and alkalosis, rows respiratory and metabolic. Respiratory acidosis is CO₂ up, pH down; respiratory alkalosis CO₂ down, pH up; metabolic acidosis bicarbonate down, pH down; metabolic alkalosis bicarbonate up, pH up. Twelve cause cards: an inhaled toy, emphysema, an opioid overdose, a panic attack, a climb to high altitude, an aspirin overdose in its first hours, diarrhea, diabetic ketoacidosis, uremia from a failing kidney, vomiting, diuretics and Cushing’s syndrome. Step 1: put each card in one of the four cells; after you commit, the metabolic acidosis cell is marked as her cell. Step 2: for each card predict whether potassium rises, falls or changes little, and choose one bedside sign from a list: noisy breaths and blue lips; slow breaths and tiny pupils; barrel chest and pursed lips; tingling lips and fingers; headache and short of breath; ringing in the ears; dry mouth and sunken eyes; deep, fast, fruity-smelling breaths; tired, itchy, deep breaths; muscle cramps and weakness; round face and stretch marks. Step 3: an aspirin overdose hours later, vomiting followed by shock, and a cardiac arrest each make a second disturbance; choose which, and whether the pair pulls the pH in opposite ways or adds up. Step 4: decide whether Stina (7.33, 33, 19, 18 breaths a minute) and Mr. Wu (7.28, 28, 14, 22 a minute) share a cell, and what separates them.

Think · not graded

Diarrhea and uremia both produce a metabolic acidosis with a normal anion gap, but one loses bicarbonate and the other fails to make it. Which is she, how would urine chemistry tell them apart, and why does the answer send you back to the slide in Chapter 5?

Spot-check your thinking: true or false?

Check · Single Choice

In a metabolic acidosis, how do the lungs compensate?

Evidence card 2

Add it to your evidence board

Her row is uremic: a kidney that cannot excrete the day’s acid or remake its base.

Scene 3 of 5

Compensation: the Healthy Organ Steps Up

Kussmaul, the edge of the range, and partial by design.

Animation · in production · 1 min 50 s

Compensation

A metabolic acidosis begins; chemoreceptors fire; breathing deepens and quickens within minutes (Kussmaul when severe); CO₂ falls; pH climbs back — and stops at the edge of the range, not the middle. A respiratory acidosis begins; the kidney reclaims and makes bicarbonate over days; pH climbs back to the edge. Partial vs complete: where the pH landed. Mr. Wu at 22 breaths a minute: lungs working as hard as lungs can. Stina at 18, a little deep: the same job, earlier. What compensation never does: fix the source.

Prefer the full lecture? Bicarbonate Buffer System (original video on the site)

Explore

Let the lungs try

pH monitor

Drop the bicarbonate and watch the lungs fight for the pH. The model sets the breathing; you predict where the pH lands.

Text description of this explore

A dark pH monitor: pH against time, with the normal band 7.35 to 7.45 shaded and the pH computed from the Henderson–Hasselbalch equation, pH = 6.1 + log(HCO₃⁻ ÷ (0.03 × PCO₂)). Step 1: the bicarbonate drops from 24 to 19 and the pH falls from 7.40; predict where it settles with no help from the lungs (CO₂ held at 40), with normal lungs (the body’s own response), and with Mr. Wu’s breathing (22 a minute, CO₂ 28): well below 7.35, slightly below, or inside the range. After you commit three curves draw: 7.30, 7.34 and 7.45. Step 2: set the bicarbonate with a slider (6 to 24 mEq/L) and choose the lungs: no help, the body’s own response (CO₂ about 1.5 × bicarbonate + 8), or all-out (CO₂ held near 15); predict whether the pH will reach 7.35, then run it. The trace, a breathing bar showing how many times normal the lungs are breathing, and a readout of bicarbonate, CO₂, breathing and pH appear. Step 3: choose the bicarbonate below which no amount of breathing reaches 7.35: about 8, about 14, about 19, or no floor. Step 4: add a healthy kidney and predict the three-day trace: climbs to the middle of the range, stops at 7.35, overshoots, or nothing for weeks; then the three-day curve draws, from 7.34 with bicarbonate 19 to 7.40 with bicarbonate 24. Step 5: label her gas, pH 7.33 with a bicarbonate of 19, partial or complete, defend it in one line, and compare with a model answer.

Think · not graded

Compensation stops at the edge of the normal range. If her lungs could pull her pH to 7.36 and did, her gas would read “compensated” and look reassuring. What would still be true of her bicarbonate, her acid load and her kidney — and what does that say about reading a single normal pH?

Spot-check your thinking: true or false?

Check · Multiple Choice

Why can’t the lungs fully correct Stina’s metabolic acidosis?

Evidence card 3

Add it to your evidence board

Her lungs are already helping; partial is what lungs can do for a kidney.

Scene 4 of 5

The ABG Game

Ten gases a level; collect lungs and kidneys.

Slide · a still to study

The 3-Level ABG Challenge

How the game works

  • Each case gives symptoms, signs and an arterial blood gas.
  • There are five answers: the four disturbances and Normal.
  • A correct respiratory call earns a lung, a correct metabolic call a kidney, and a correct Normal both. A mistake costs one.
  • There are three levels of ten cases.

The game’s tip is the notes’ first step: read the pH first.

The notes’ three questions, scored.

Open the 3-Level ABG Challenge

Prefer the full lecture? Bicarbonate Buffer System (original video on the site)

Game

Earn a kidney

ABG arcade

A prediction wrapper for the site’s 3-Level ABG Challenge. Before each case, choose the one number you want to see first and why; then play the cases and collect lungs and kidneys.

Text description of this game

An arcade wrapper around the site’s ABG game. Step 1: five cases lie face down with only their story showing: a 19-year-old thirsty for days with deep, fast, fruity breathing; someone found asleep after pain pills with blue lips and four breaths a minute; three days of vomiting, weak and twitchy; exam panic with tingling lips and fingers; and a routine check with no complaints. For each, choose the one number to see first (pH, PCO₂, HCO₃⁻ or PO₂) and why (it frames the other two, because it says acid or base; the symptoms hint at it; it is the most abnormal). Step 2: an arcade scoreboard for level 1 with a lung and a kidney icon; the gases are shown (7.23, 22, 9, PO₂ 98; 7.26, 62, 27, PO₂ 52; 7.50, 46, 35, PO₂ 88; 7.57, 25, 22, PO₂ 108; 7.41, 39, 24, PO₂ 95). Name each with the game’s five answers (respiratory acidosis, respiratory alkalosis, metabolic acidosis, metabolic alkalosis, normal) and choose what it earns in the game (a lung, a kidney, or both); after you commit, each case says which of the three questions a wrong call skipped, and the scoreboard shows how many paid out. Step 3: predict which question most wrong calls skip. Step 4: her gas (7.33, 33, 19, PO₂ 94) as a sixth case: name it and what it earns; the reveal links to the site’s 3-Level ABG Challenge.

Think · not graded

The game rewards a respiratory call with a lung and a metabolic call with a kidney. After ten cases, which organ did you earn more of — and which of the three questions do your mistakes cluster on?

Spot-check your thinking: true or false?

Check · Question Set

Five gases from the game, named.

Evidence card 4

Add it to your evidence board

Ten cases, three questions each; the method holds for every one, including hers.

Scene 5 of 5

When the Slow Partner Fails

Fixed acid, new bicarbonate, potassium, bone.

Animation · in production · 2 min

When the Slow Partner Fails

Two renal jobs lost: excrete the day’s fixed acid (40–70 mEq — phosphate, sulfate, organic acids; only the kidney) and make new bicarbonate (the glutamine machine slowing; urine ammonium falling). Where the acid goes: bicarbonate, hemoglobin, intracellular phosphate — and over years, bone, which gives up carbonate and thins (the DEXA at 38). The potassium ride: H⁺ in, K⁺ out; a kidney that struggles with potassium handed more (4.9). The lungs: as deep as needed, forever — and never a new bicarbonate. Partial by design. The fix is the organ: protect the filter, slow the amyloid; a bicarbonate tablet buys time.

Prefer the full lecture? pH and Buffers (original video on the site)

Explore

Two jobs lost

Kidney console

A kidney with two dials and four readouts. Turn the dials down and predict before the readouts draw; then add the lungs, then three treatments, and watch the ten-year bone line.

Text description of this explore

A kidney console. The kidney has two dials, both set as a percentage of normal: “acid out” (excreting the day’s fixed acid; in this model titratable acid carries about a third of the day’s 60 mEq) and “new HCO₃⁻” (the glutamine machine, whose ammonium carries about two-thirds). Beside it are four readouts: bicarbonate, pH (from pH = 6.1 + log(HCO₃⁻ ÷ (0.03 × PCO₂))), potassium, and bone mineral after ten years as a percentage of today, drawn as a ten-year line beside a dashed line for a healthy kidney. Step 1: both dials are turned down to 75%, about where her kidney sits, with the lungs off; predict whether each readout goes up, goes down or stays put; then the readouts draw (bicarbonate 19, pH 7.30, potassium 5.1, bone 84.5% against 92%). Step 2: set each dial to 100, 75, 50 or 25% and the lungs off or on; predict whether all four readouts are worse than a healthy kidney’s, only the pH, or none; run it to see the readouts and the acid left over each day. Step 3: for a bicarbonate tablet, an ACE inhibitor and “slow the amyloid”, predict which readout each mainly moves (bicarbonate and pH, potassium, or none of the four this month) and whether it changes the kidney’s dials. Step 4: run ten years with nothing, a tablet, an ACE inhibitor, “slow the amyloid”, or tablet plus “slow the amyloid”; predict whether the bone line ends higher on a straight line, higher but still steepening, or about the same; a chart draws the line against doing nothing and a readout gives the dials, bicarbonate, pH, potassium and bone lost in year 1 and year 10. Step 5: choose the one intervention that changes the course of the ten-year bone line.

Think · not graded

Bone buffers a chronic acid load by giving up carbonate — slowly, for years. Her bone density was low at thirty-eight, long before any bicarbonate flag. What are the possible authors of that scan now (inflammation, cortisol, menopause, acid), how would you weigh them — and why is “it was perimenopause” the least interesting of the four?

Spot-check your thinking: true or false?

Check · Mixed Quiz

The failing kidney in five questions.

Evidence card 5

Add it to your evidence board

Two renal jobs lost; lungs, hemoglobin and bone covering what they can — and the fix is the filter.

4

Your evidence board

Every scene gave you an evidence card, and the chart adds more. Sort each card into the column it supports: A partially compensated metabolic acidosis from a failing kidney, Neither on its own, or A respiratory disturbance, or no disturbance at all. Some cards can honestly go in more than one place — that’s allowed, and the feedback tells you which cards decide the case.

5

Your verdict

Time to decide. Look back at your bet, then build your verdict from statements that hold up — no writing needed.

Look back at your prediction

pH 7.33, PCO₂ 33, HCO₃⁻ 19, breathing a little deep — her lungs…

Find the one you chose at the top. Does the evidence support it, refute it, or revise it?

  • Have failed to compensate — a compensated acidosis would have a normal pH
  • Are compensating as far as lungs can — they can blow off CO₂ but cannot make bicarbonate or excrete a fixed acid
  • Are the problem — a low CO₂ is a respiratory disturbance by definition

Build your verdict · no writing

Choose the statement that holds in each set. The ones you keep become your argument.

6

The finding

Finding · renal metabolic acidosis, only partly compensated

A Patch Over a Hole the Lungs Cannot Fill

pH 7.33, PCO₂ 33, HCO₃⁻ 19, PO₂ 94; respirations 18 and slightly deep; anion gap 10; urine pH 5.0 with ammonium low for the acidosis; potassium 4.9; eGFR 48; a bone scan low at 38. Read in the notes’ three steps: acidosis; metabolic, with the respiratory system compensating; bicarbonate low; partially compensated. Chart entry: a kidney with amyloid in it is losing the two jobs only a kidney does — excrete the day’s fixed acid and remake bicarbonate — and the lungs, hemoglobin and bone are covering what they can. The gas was filed without a word. The next chapter lays all three findings on one filter and logs the clue.

Next · Chapter 7

One Filter, Not Three Problems

Edema, a “low” calcium, an acid drift — three problems, three errands, or one leaking filter read from three angles? Chart Clue #20, and the ledger a kidney keeps.

Reliable information on rare diseases

NORD · NIH GARD · Orphanet · MedlinePlus Genetics: FMF · FMF & AID Global Association · Autoinflammatory Alliance · Global Genes · Amyloidosis Foundation

Stina has one rare disease. In the United States, about 1 in 10 people live with one of the more than 7,000 known rare diseases. These organizations are where patients, families and clinicians go for trustworthy information.

List of terms